“These Days … It Is Safest to Be Circumspect and Cautious”

That’s in China, of course; see this article in today’s L.A. Times (Alice Su) (seemingly unpaywalled, or only light paywalled, here). An excerpt: The professor [Sun Piedong of Fudan University] was under surveillance. Cameras taped her every lecture…. She knew she had to be careful when she taught on one of China’s most sensitive and dangerous topics: the … Continue reading “These Days … It Is Safest to Be Circumspect and Cautious” Continue Reading →

Mask Mandates and Broccoli Mandates

One of the most enduring images of the constitutional challenge to Obamacare was broccoli. Indeed, I briefly considered (and thankfully rejected) the idea of putting broccoli on the front cover of Unprecedented. Could the government force you to buy broccoli, the argument went? Of course, NFIB v. Sebelius was not about broccoli mandates. The litigation asserted that Congress … Continue reading Mask Mandates and Broccoli Mandates Continue Reading →

With Chief in Charge, SCOTUS Strikes Down Louisiana Abortion Law and Eliminates CFPB Independence (Updated)

The Supreme Court handed down three big opinions today, each of which was closely divided. Here is a quick run down, with more to follow on these cases in later posts by various VC contributors. First, the Court decided Agency for International Development v. Alliance for Open Society International, upholding a limitation on USAID grant funding … Continue reading With Chief in Charge, SCOTUS Strikes Down Louisiana Abortion Law and Eliminates CFPB Independence (Updated) Continue Reading →

My Jotwell Review of Lindsay Wiley and Steve Vladeck’s “Coronavirus, Civil Liberties, and the Courts”

My latest contribution to the Jotwell website constitutional law section (which reviews important recent legal scholarship) focuses on Lindsay Wiley and Steve Vladeck’s excellent forthcoming article, “Coronavirus, Civil Liberties, and the Courts: The Case Against ‘Suspending’ Judicial Review,” which will soon be out from the Harvard Law Review Forum. Here is an excerpt from my review: The coronavirus epidemic … Continue reading My Jotwell Review of Lindsay Wiley and Steve Vladeck’s “Coronavirus, Civil Liberties, and the Courts” Continue Reading →

Reason TV Video on the Case for Letting Hong Kong Refugees Migrate to the United States

Reason TV has posted a video in which I and others make the case for allowing Hong Kongers to immigrate to the United States, in the wake of a recent Chinese law that gravely threatens the relative freedom that has prevailed in Hong Kong until recently. In the video, I also argue for extending the … Continue reading Reason TV Video on the Case for Letting Hong Kong Refugees Migrate to the United States Continue Reading →

Communications With Reputation Repair Firm Aren’t Privileged

From Brummer v. Wey,  2020 WL 3494657, decided by Judge Lucy Billings on Jan. 17, but just posted on Westlaw: [D]efendants [Benjamin] Wey and NYG Capital move to compel production of 33 documents that plaintiff [Prof. Christopher Brummer] and FINRA [the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority] claim are protected from disclosure … as attorney work product or … Continue reading Communications With Reputation Repair Firm Aren’t Privileged Continue Reading →

When Can You Threaten Deadly Force as a Defensive Tactic?

This question is in the news because of the St. Louis controversy (see, e.g., here and here); but I thought I’d discuss it more broadly, because the answer is surprisingly unsettled. [1.] To begin with, recall that, as a general matter, you can lawfully use deadly force to prevent death, serious bodily injury, kidnapping, or rape, if you reasonably fear such … Continue reading When Can You Threaten Deadly Force as a Defensive Tactic? Continue Reading →

Blue June Glooms On

I have now finished reading June Medical Services and Seila Law. Collectively, they total 243 pages! Both cases are now edited for the Barnett/Blackman supplement–down to 26 pages each. It took me all day. If you’d like a copy, please e-mail me: josh-at-josh-blackman-dot-com. Last week I predicted that Roberts would write June Medical and Breyer would write Seila Law. I whiffed on Seila. I … Continue reading Blue June Glooms On Continue Reading →

The Chief Justices Battle over the Removal Power

Seila Law was the Court’s most significant separation of powers case since Noel Canning. Yet, this decision is–at best–a symbolic victory for conservatives; not nearly enough to staunch the June gloom. I don’t think people will embroider “Overrule Humphrey’s Executor” on red baseball hats. As a practical matter, this case will have little impact. Whether the President can fire … Continue reading The Chief Justices Battle over the Removal Power Continue Reading →

Bill Barr Crosses the Rubicon

For the first time in twenty years, the Justice Department is finally free to campaign for the encryption access bill it has always wanted.  Sens. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), Tom Cotton (R-Ark.), and Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) introduced the Lawful Access To Encrypted Data Act. (Ars Technica, Press Release) As Nick Weaver points out in the news roundup, this bill … Continue reading Bill Barr Crosses the Rubicon Continue Reading →