Hoffman and Hwang on Contracts Not Performed Because of Pandemic

David Hoffman and Cathy Hwang have written an article entitled “The Social Cost of Contract,” arguing that the public is a third party to every contract and considering the relevance of that in determining whether courts should enforce contracts whose performance would have been inadvisable given the Covid-19 pandemic. The article is elegantly written, situating specific questions … Continue reading Hoffman and Hwang on Contracts Not Performed Because of Pandemic Continue Reading →

400 Princeton Faculty Demand Committee for “Investigation and Discipline of Racist … Research and Publication”

  The relevant paragraph: Constitute a committee composed entirely of faculty that would oversee the investigation and discipline of racist behaviors, incidents, research, and publication on the part of faculty, following a protocol for grievance and appeal to be spelled out in Rules and Procedures of the Faculty. Guidelines on what counts as racist behavior, incidents, … Continue reading 400 Princeton Faculty Demand Committee for “Investigation and Discipline of Racist … Research and Publication” Continue Reading →

Restrictions on Personalized License Plates “Offensive to Good Taste and Decency” Likely Unconstitutional

Today’s decision by Judge Jon S. Tigar in Ogilvie v. Gordon (N.D. Cal.) concludes that the personalized license plates (unlike license plate background designs) are private speech, not government speech: Walker v. Sons of Confederate Veterans [which held that license plate designs were government speech -EV] explicitly did not consider whether the alphanumeric combinations approved via Texas’s personalization … Continue reading Restrictions on Personalized License Plates “Offensive to Good Taste and Decency” Likely Unconstitutional Continue Reading →

The Penultimate Day of Overtime July: Religious Liberty Wednesday

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court decided two religious liberty cases. First, Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey-Berru expanded the so-called ministerial exception beyond the scope of Hosannah Tabor v. EEOC. Justice Alito did little to stifle retirement rumors with his citation in Footnote 16 to The Benedict Option. Second, Little Sisters of the Poor Saints Peter and Paul Home … Continue reading The Penultimate Day of Overtime July: Religious Liberty Wednesday Continue Reading →

BREAKING: Supreme Court Decides Trump Financial Records Cases and Fate of Eastern Oklahoma (Updated)

The Supreme Court issued its final decisions of the term today, resolving the long-running dispute over Donald Trump’s financial records and the status of eastern Oklahoma. The Court resoundingly rejected claims of Presidential immunity, but also roundly rejected the House of Representatives’ claims of unlimited investigatory authority. The Court also ruled in favor of Native … Continue reading BREAKING: Supreme Court Decides Trump Financial Records Cases and Fate of Eastern Oklahoma (Updated) Continue Reading →

Are We Living in Crazytown?

The anti-cancel culture letter published in Harper’s and signed by various intellectuals ranging ideologically from Noam Chomsky to Steven Pinker, and the harsh reaction to it from many “progressive” activists, has been covered in detail elsewhere. But two specific reactions to the relevant controversy really made me feel like we are  living in Crazytown. First, several Vox employees publicly … Continue reading Are We Living in Crazytown? Continue Reading →

Preliminary Thoughts on the Mazars and Vance Cases [Updated with Link to my SCOTUSblog Article on Mazars]

Earlier today, the Supreme Court issued complex 7-2 decisions in Trump v. Vance and Trump v. Mazars. In the former case, the Court ruled that state courts may subpoena the president’s financial records in a state criminal case and that there is no “heightened standard” for a subpoena in such cases. In Mazars, the Court vacated lower court decisions uphold … Continue reading Preliminary Thoughts on the Mazars and Vance Cases [Updated with Link to my SCOTUSblog Article on Mazars] Continue Reading →

Are Minneapolis Crime Increases Evidence of a “Ferguson Effect”?

Following the police killing of George Floyd and subsequent civil unrest in Minneapolis, some crimes–specifically gun crimes–have increased in that city while other kinds of crimes have not.  A”Ferguson effect” appears to explain this pattern. Minneapolis police have stopped making as many street stops as they made previously.  And given the unique responsiveness of gun … Continue reading Are Minneapolis Crime Increases Evidence of a “Ferguson Effect”? Continue Reading →

“A Better Way to Limit Congress’ Subpoena Power”—My SCOTUSblog Symposium Article on Trump v. Mazars

My SCOTUSblog symposium article on the Supreme Court’s decision in Trump v. Mazars is now up. The article criticizes some aspects of the majority opinion and Justice Thomas’ dissent, and outlines a better way to limit Congress’ power to subpoena documents. Here is an excerpt: Today’s Supreme Court decision in Trump v. Mazars establishes a vague and unwieldy four-part test for … Continue reading “A Better Way to Limit Congress’ Subpoena Power”—My SCOTUSblog Symposium Article on Trump v. Mazars Continue Reading →