Headlines

INDONESIA: Confusion Reins in Blast Aftermath

Fabio Scarpello

JAKARTA, Sep 13 2004 (IPS) - Indonesian civil society has been united in condemning the bombing that killed nine and injured at least 180 in the capital’s main commercial district last week. But differences emerged on who was to blame for the blast outside the Australian embassy and how to prevent another attack from taking place in a country where terrorists hide behind religion and religion often overlaps with politics.

Indonesian civil society has been united in condemning the bombing that killed nine and injured at least 180 in the capital’s main commercial district last week. But, while fresh warnings were issued on Saturday, differences emerged on who was to blame for the blast outside the Australian embassy and how to prevent another attack from taking place in a country where terrorists hide behind religion and religion often overlaps with politics.

”In Indonesia, the border between religion and politics is blurred and terrorists exploit it,” said Nathan Setiabudi, chairman of the Indonesian Communion of Churches.

”The government should differentiate between religion and terror. These people have to be treated as criminals and not as religious extremists. The fact that they act under the umbrella of Islam is an attempt to confuse the public,” he told IPS.

According to Indonesian and Australian police investigators, Thursday’s blast is linked to Jemaiah Islamiyah (JI) – a regional network that aims to create a pan-Islamic state in South-east Asia and which several governments have classified as a terrorist organisation.

The Australian embassy warned that more attacks ”could not be ruled out” and urged Australians to avoid the area around the mission, including the huge Rasuna apartment complex where a number of Westerners live. The U.S. embassy e-mailed similar warnings to Americans.


JI is alleged to be responsible for the Bali bombing in October 2002 and the Jakarta JW Marriott Hotel bombing in August 2003, killing 202 and 14 people respectively.

Although Indonesia has since managed to bring to justice and condemn most of the perpetrators of those attacks, foreign analysts have often defined the country as ”too cautious” in dealing with Islamic militants. Indonesia is the world’s largest Muslim country, where 85 percent of the 220 million people profess the Islamic faith.

However, Dewi Fortuna Anwar, director of programme and research at the Habibie Centre – a local think-tank – begged to differ.

”The government has worked hard. The police have improved a lot and Indonesia has been effective in bringing the culprits to justice, compared to other countries,” she said in an interview.

But she added: ”It is nonetheless obvious that much more needs to be done.”

Anwar noted that since all the victims in Thursday’s blast were Indonesians, it would be easier for the government to rally the people’s support.

”It is awful to say that, but if the victims were foreigners some people would have not spoken out against it, but now nobody wants to be associated with a terrorist group that kills local civilians,” she said.

Seemingly in concurrence with that view, in the last few days the country’s two biggest moderate Islamic Associations, Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah, have been joined in their condemnation of the bombing by the normally uncompromising Hizbut Tahrir group and, ironically, by JI’s Abu Bakar Bashir.

Bashir, the accused spiritual leader of JI who is currently in detention in Jakarta, awaiting trial, told the local newspaper ‘Indo Pos’: ”An action like that (Thursday’s terror attack) is not a way to fight to uphold the Islamic Syariah law.”

Anwar goes on to argue that the root of the problem is the anger in the Islamic world at the United States and its allies’ foreign policies in the Middle East and Iraq. But she called on local ”imams” or religious leaders to be careful with their exhortations.

”They have to make it clear that dissatisfaction with U.S. policies does not justify terrorism, especially when reported in the media,” she said.

The link between local terrorism and the United States’ foreign policy was also emphasised by Arbi Sanit, a lecturer in Politics at University of Indonesia, as well as Indria Samego, military expert at Indonesia Institute of Sciences (LIPI).

”Radical militants are different from average Muslims and it is very difficult to persuade them. These people have made up their mind to fight U.S. imperialism and unless the world scenario changes, there is only so much Indonesia can do,” Sanit told IPS.

Samego agreed and accepted that in Indonesia there had long been a fringe of radical Islamists. ”These people interpret the Koran literally and consider non Muslims as enemies,” he said.

However, two major bombings in a city in the space of one year means that someone is not doing their job properly and experts differ on who is to blame and what needs to be improved.

Anwar, while blaming the Indonesian Intelligence Service (BIN), urged caution.

”We have to strengthen our intelligence, which is essential for a better national security, but we have to be careful not to compromise our (stance on) human rights and make the same mistakes as in the past,” she said.

Between 1965 and 1998, Indonesia was under strong-man Suharto who abused the State’s power for political means.

”Back then, anyone presumed to be an activist was arrested,” added Anwar.

LPI’s Samego widened the net to include the police force as one of the negligent parties. ”The police and BIN have failed in their duties to provide security, and the president [Megawati Sukarnoputri] should replace the respective heads [of those institutions],” he said.

According to Samego, national security has also suffered as a result of the split of the Indonesian Military (TNI) and the police in 2000. ”The division weakened the security apparatus and we are in urgent need of legislation that will give more power to the TNI, who have suffered the most,” he argued.

U.S.-born Ken Conboy, author of ‘Kopassus: Indonesia’s Special Forces at war’,and expert in South-east Asian military affairs, pointed the finger firmly at the police.

On Friday, according to Australia, Indonesian police were warned 45 minutes before the blast outside the Australian embassy that Western missions would be attacked if JI’s Bashir was not released.

Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer told a news conference in Jakarta the warning to release Bashir, the accused spiritual leader of an al Qaeda-linked militant group, was conveyed in a phone text message to an elite police unit.

”(They) received an SMS message about 45 minutes before the attack yesterday that there would be an attack on Western embassies unless Abu Bakar Bashir was released,” Downer said.

Conboy insisted that the problem is with law enforcement and that the lack of coordination and unitary direction among the various police corps made it much worse.

”They have different brigadiers and different sources. They all collect material but they do not share it and there is not one office to compile or analyse it,” he said, adding that in such a system most of the material becomes useless, with the result being that the threat of terrorism will remain.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Asia-Pacific, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

INDONESIA: Confusion Reins in Blast Aftermath

Fabio Scarpello

JAKARTA, Sep 13 2004 (IPS) - Indonesian civil society has been united in condemning the bombing that killed nine and injured at least 180 in the capital’s main commercial district last week. But, while fresh warnings were issued on Saturday, differences emerged on who was to blame for the blast outside the Australian embassy and how to prevent another attack from taking place in a country where terrorists hide behind religion and religion often overlaps with politics.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags